Français
Español
English
Portuguese
by Mike Fegelman
Source: HonestReporting.ca
There’s an important line separating legitimate opinion that enhances the public discourse, from hateful rhetoric that interferes with constructive dialogue.
When the Toronto Star published a commentary on August 4 by Reverend Lawrence Pushee justifying terrorism against the Israeli Olympians at the 72’ Munich games, Canada’s most read daily newspaper saw its respected news platform exploited by a protagonist who seeks to demonize and vilify Jews and the State of Israel.
Responding to a Star editorial which had taken a principled stance in calling on the International Olympic Committee (IOC) to hold a moment of silence at the opening ceremonies in memory of the murdered Israeli athletes and coaches killed by Palestinian terrorists, Rev. Pushee abhorrently declared the following:
“That was indeed a horrible and shocking moment for the international community and such an observance would be welcomed by most of us, but only if it were a balanced time for remembering. The Palestinian assassins targeted Israelis because for decades their people had been assassinated by Israeli agents and members of its occupation forces. Munich didn’t just happen out of the blue. To remember the loss at Munich and not remember the suffering of the Palestinians would be to continue the untruth that Israel is the constant victim.”
In other words, Pushee was claiming that while the cold-blooded murder of these Israeli civilians was bad, they essentially had it coming to them in so much as Israeli security forces had allegedly killed Palestinians. Why Toronto Star editors elected to publish a commentary justifying terror against innocents is bewildering.
To wit, would the Toronto Star dare publish a letter marking the 9/11 terror attacks arguing that the murder of close to 3,000 innocent people by Al Qaeda was understandable given U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East?
Would the Star publish a letter that sympathized with Timothy McVeigh for his role in carrying out the Oklahoma City Bombing that killed 168 people and injured over 800 people?
Would the Star publish a letter that excused and rationalized the murder of gays, blacks, and aboriginal Canadians? We trust that Toronto Star editors would responsibly discard such commentary into the dustbin of history, but why does the Toronto Star hold Israeli Jews to a different standard by tolerating commentary that justifies their murder?
Reverend Pushee is no stranger to controversy and is well known for his anti-Semitic remarks and vitriolic hatred of Israel. He once claimed that Canada’s Environment Minister was complicit with ”Zionist genocide, ethnic cleansing and weapons testing in Gaza”.
He dismissed past abductions of Israeli soldiers as a “mere embarrassment” and outrageously asserted that Israel intentionally targets UN installations, schools, and hospitals using depleted uranium. It’s also been reported that he described Israelis as (among other things) a “greedy,” “Mafia style” administration with a “deficiency in intelligence and even the United Church of Canada (UCC), well known especially nowadays for its vociferous criticism of Israel, ousted Reverend Pushee from a leadership position for his vile anti-Israel remarks.
HonestReporting Canada ardently supports free expression and strongly defends the right to offend, but Reverend Pushee’s comments crossed the line. That is why we appealed to Toronto Star editors to “unpublish’ this letter from the Star’s website. Yet in response, the Star regrettably defended their publication of this commentary stating: “We have discussed the points you raise and we do not think that any action is warranted by the Star. Letters to the editor reflect the opinion of the writer and we try to publish letters that provide a wide range of points of views.”
The Star also declined to publish our rebuttal to this inflammatory letter displaying a lack of commitment in providing a diversity of opinion on this issue. That the Star actually believes that Pushee’s remarks add to the marketplace of ideas shows a remarkable lack of judgement on the part of their editorial team.
By giving a platform for this letter to be published in perpetuity on the Star’s website, the Toronto Star has been used and has become a tool that fans the flames of hatred against Israel and Jews
“HOW YOU CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE”
Forward your comments to the Toronto Star’s Public Editor, condemning the Star’s publication of a letter that justifies terrorism against Israeli Olympians.
Send your email to: publiced@thestar.ca
THANK YOU TO BUDDY MACY FOR YOUR RESPONSE TO THE REVEREND’S COMMENTS
Buddy Macy of Little Falls, New Jersey wrote this letter response to Reverend Pushee’s comments:
Rev. Pushee, your display of ignorance and extreme anti-Semitism is shocking; especially, when considering your position of power and influence. How dare you try to justify the terrorist murderers’ actions of torturing and killing innocent Olympians! By so doing, you are granting permission for any one to retaliate against another, whether or not that other person was involved in the perceived injustice, or not. Applying your argument, Jews would have the right to murder Italians (Romans), Spaniards, Germans, Egyptians, Jordanians, Syrians, Lebanese and Iraqis, for starters!
And, in regard to your statement about Israel’s “decades’ long assault” on the suffering Arab-“Palestinians”, somehow I seem to recall five wars waged against Israel by her Arab neighbors in an effort to destroy the Jewish State, and the Arab-“Palestinians'” firing of thousands of rockets into southern Israel during the past 7 years from some of the very land Israel unilaterally and completely handed over to them in August 2005, in the name of “peace.” The Arabs continue to attempt to kill as many Israeli men, women and children as possible, and to create terror in the minds and hearts of all Israelis. It has not worked, and it never will. Israel will defend herself against the hate-filled terrorists and do whatever is necessary to ensure her citizens’ security.
In case you have the least bit of interest in learning the truth about Israel and the Arab-“Palestinians”, I urge you to read this well-documented, fully-notated article.
Most sincerely,
Buddy Macy
Little Falls, NJ
Forward your comments to the Toronto Star’s Public Editor, condemning the Star’s publication of a letter that justifies terrorism against Israeli Olympians.
Send your email to: publiced@thestar.ca
Please ‘SHARE’ with your family and friends – we need YOU to spread the word!
Do You Love Israel? Make a Donation - Show Your Support!
Donate to vital charities that help protect Israeli citizens and inspire millions around the world to support Israel too!
Now more than ever, Israel needs your help to fight and win the war -- including on the battlefield of public opinion.
Antisemitism, anti-Israel bias and boycotts are out of control. Israel's enemies are inciting terror and violence against innocent Israelis and Jews around the world. Help us fight back!
