“This concerted effort to drive down reviews as a way to harm individuals and not a political entity is what ends up being problematic and downright antisemitic.”
By Faygie Holt, JNS.org
Online restaurant reviews are the latest battleground for anti-Israel activists who have recently targeted a kosher eatery in New Jersey with a barrage of antisemitic comments, including claiming that the food was “stolen.”
Located on what is referred to as a relatively small “kosher restaurant row” in Teaneck, N.J., Yalla is not on a major thoroughfare nor does it have a clientele base from outside of the Northern New Jersey Jewish community. What it does have, however, is an Arabic name—yalla, which is commonly used in Israel and means “let’s go”—and that has attracted some online attention, though not in a good way.
According to Yalla’s owner, Jacob Goldberg, who is Israeli, over the last few years, he has gotten a number of one-star reviews from people claiming: “I stole their land; I stole the name; I stole the food. It has nothing to do with anything here. It’s ridiculous.”
Most of the time, Goldberg simply flags the reviews on Google and asks that they be removed. “Sometimes,” he explains, “it’s very obviously hate speech, and it comes down. But if it’s food-related—like I found a hair in my food—even though someone from Damascus is posting it and has obviously never been to my restaurant, the computer doesn’t flag it.”
So Goldberg decided to take a new tactic; last week, he responded to the review himself, setting off a firestorm as the poster urged Palestinian supporters via social media to add more one-star, or unfavorable, reviews of Yalla. A TikTok video was even posted by one woman who said, “So this Israeli restaurant in Teaneck, N.J., is falsely advertising Palestinian, Middle Eastern food. This is what their menu looks like, falafel and shawarma. Uh no. So, us Palestinians have to do the job. They messed with the wrong people. … Free Palestine.”
Within hours, Yalla’s 4.6-star rating (out of a maximum of five stars) dropped to under 3.9 and then even lower all the way to a 2.8. The review listings were suddenly filled with comments like: “Stolen Palestinian food and the owner has left his manner … cultural appropriation at it’s [sic] finest … bad place DON’T GO THERE AND WASTE YOUR MONEY!!!” and “No one food on here is ‘Israeli.’ Keep it moving guys this place is absolutely trash and their food has NO taste yet overpriced. They steal the thoughts and the lands and serve you s**t on a plate. Never again.”
‘A Digital Force Instead of Physical Means’
Liora Rez, executive director of Stop Antisemitism, said “to target a kosher restaurant in New Jersey and hold it responsible for a global political conflict is undeniably antisemitic.”
“Rather than participating in targeted harassment campaigns against innocent Jewish business owners, we would prefer to see Palestinian youths participating in peace and normalization initiatives that would help both Jews and Arabs alike,” she said.
Goldberg believes there were at least 300 one-star reviews posted that night, some of which also included Palestinian flags and the words “Free Palestine.”
“In real life, if you get attacked, you call 9-1-1 and the police respond, but if you get attacked online, nothing, nothing, nothing happens. … A 5-year-old can look at these reviews and tell they are fake, yet Google—a multibillion-dollar company—can’t flag something like this a fake is just pretty astonishing.”
After having no luck reaching out to Google himself, Goldberg reported the incident to the Anti-Defamation League, which confirmed it is a case of antisemitism.
“This concerted effort to drive down reviews as a way to harm individuals and not a political entity is what ends up being problematic and downright antisemitic,” said Alexander Rosemberg, deputy regional director of the ADL NY/NJ Region. “It is absolutely wrong.”
“ … It’s like picking on someone to target in the middle of Times Square because he is wearing a yarmulke; it’s just a digital force instead of physical means,” he added.
According to Rosemberg, the ADL’s Center for Technology and Society maintains contact with the Big Tech companies and is currently speaking with Google about the Yalla incident.
“We should all be very educated and very aware about the processes and procedures that these platforms have put in place to denounce harmful and nefarious behavior,” he said, noting that the ADL has a cyber-safety action guide to help people know their rights.
Though the number of antisemitic and anti-Israel reviews was troublesome, what happened next, said Goldberg, was heartening. Several Jewish and pro-Israel groups, including Raz’s organization, StopAntiSemitism.org, rallied to counter the negative reviews helping to drive Yalla’s rankings back to where they had been before the cyber fight.
According to Goldberg, since the news of the cyber battle broke on Sunday, people have been stopping into Yalla “just to show their support.” As United With Israel reported earlier in January, Israel supporters boosted the eatery’s review status to 4.7 stars.
And that, Goldberg said, “feels amazing.”
When asked if the press would cause a spike in business, he replied: “In the short term, I’ve been getting a lot of support from Jews who felt they had to come out and fight hate. I don’t think there will be much impact in the long term. I spoke to many people who think Google reviews are mostly fake anyway, especially if you see pro-Palestinian reviews. They trust the old-fashioned way of reviews from friends and family. So probably not much impact.”
United With Israel Staff contributed to this report.
Bring Joy to Israeli Soldiers - Send Winter Care Packages!
We are honored to thank the young men and women of the IDF who risk their lives every day to defend the citizens of Israel.
Join us in sending winter care packages and personal notes of support to Israeli soldiers who are out in the cold all day.
Warm up a soldier's heart with essential winter wear including fleece jackets, hats, gloves and more. Keep an entire unit warm!
THE SOLDIERS REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR LOVE AND CONCERN!