The New York Times has repeatedly provided Piker with a prestigious platform on which his most extreme positions can be presented as serious political ideas.
By Rachel O’Donoghue, HonestReporting
The New York Times has an Israel obsession. It also has a Hasan Piker obsession. And Piker, never one to pass up an opportunity for self-promotion or Israel-bashing, is also obsessed with both.
The result is a seemingly endless parade of coverage featuring the socialist streamer: two profiles, three podcast appearances, guest essays, and an Ezra Klein column originally titled “Hasan Piker Is Not the Enemy”—a headline the paper changed amid backlash over its defense of a man who once declared that “America deserved 9/11.”
The latest installment was an 86-minute sit-down with Klein, in which Israel occupied much of the agenda.
Throughout the interview, the words “Israel” and “Israeli” were mentioned 64 times. “Zionist” and “Zionists” came up another 30 times.
By comparison, “America,” “American,” and “Americans” were mentioned just 38 times.
And this was ostensibly an interview about the future of the Democratic Party.
For a man who claims to be committed to “redistributing power and the means of production from the capital-owning class to the working class,” Piker doesn’t get preoccupied with explaining how, exactly, he intends to achieve it.
So instead we have an hour on Israel. Apparently, seizing the means of production can wait.
First, there’s the small matter of dismantling the Jewish state.
Here, in no particular order, are some of Piker’s latest pronouncements on Israel:
On whether Hamas is motivated by hatred of Jews:
“The attitude is that they are expressly animated by Jewish hatred. That’s not the case. If Israel were a Christian nationalist ethnostate, then the violence and the attitude would look like they’re anti-Christian. It is a national emancipatory front. That’s all they care about: the end to the occupation.”
On the October 7 massacre:
“There were war crimes that took place. I mean, it was horrifying. I’ve never condoned October seven. Having said that, I understand the ways in which October seven unfolded almost became an inevitability, really.”
On whether liberal Zionists are comparable to Nazis: in footage from an earlier appearance, Piker said, “Zionism is an exterminationist ideology built around ethno […] religious supremacist values.”
On Jewish voters and the Ku Klux Klan: Klein played an earlier clip in which Piker compared canvassing a predominantly Jewish district for Abdul El-Sayed to campaigning for a Black candidate in a KKK neighborhood.
When Klein asked whether Piker’s own Nazi and KKK comparisons might explain some Jewish people’s hostility toward him, Piker responded:
“I think that there is no difference between a KKK member and what I’m describing in my personal experience and what I’ve seen and what I’ve heard and what my anti-Zionist Jewish friends have talked about in terms of their own conversations.”
On Israel’s security arguments: “The Nazis made a false security concern argument as well.”
On what the United States should do to Israel: “Shut off all aid, all arms transfers, and the memorandum of understanding immediately, and apply maximum pressure to the Israeli government.”
Start with Hamas. Klein, to his credit, pressed Piker on his previous assertion that the terrorist group was “1,000 times better than the Israeli government” and asked whether October 7 constituted terrorism.
Piker acknowledged that war crimes had been committed and that attacking civilians was unacceptable.
But the scrutiny largely ended there. Piker proceeded to offer a grotesquely charitable account of Hamas’s motives, which Klein failed to challenge.
“The attitude is that they are expressly animated by Jew hatred,” Piker insisted. “That’s not the case.” Hamas, he claimed, is “a national emancipatory front” concerned only with “the end to the occupation.”
Israel dismantled its settlements and withdrew its permanent ground forces from Gaza in 2005.
On October 7, Hamas crossed into Israel to massacre civilians in their homes, slaughter festivalgoers, and abduct hostages.
Piker instead points to Judea and Samaria. But Palestinian violence against Jews long predates Israel’s capture of Judea and Samaria and eastern Jerusalem in 1967—territories Israel took from Jordan during the Six-Day War, after Jordan attacked Israel and shelled Jerusalem.
In 1929, Arab rioters massacred 67 Jews in Hebron, almost two decades before the modern state of Israel existed.
In 1938, Arab gunmen murdered Jews in Tiberias, including women and children. In 1956, fedayeen gunmen murdered Jewish children and their teacher at a religious school in Kfar Chabad.
The Palestine Liberation Organization itself was founded in 1964, three years before Israel took control of Judea and Samaria.
Nor has Palestinian terrorism confined itself to Israel.
Palestinian terrorists attacked Jewish children in Antwerp in 1980, synagogue worshippers in Vienna in 1981, a Jewish restaurant in Paris in 1982, Rome’s Great Synagogue that same year and Istanbul’s Neve Shalom synagogue in 1986.
These attacks were carried out by other Palestinian terrorist factions that predated Hamas.
But they expose a longstanding pattern of deliberately targeting Jewish civilians thousands of miles from any battlefield.
And Hamas’s own record is no less damning.
Its 1988 founding charter explicitly identified its struggle as one against “the Jews,” while Article 7 invoked a prophecy about killing them.
In 2019, senior Hamas figure Fathi Hammad urged Palestinians abroad to “attack every Jew on the globe.”
More recently, in March 2026, a Berlin court convicted four Hamas members involved in stockpiling weapons for potential terrorist attacks in Europe.
Separate German investigations have uncovered plots to attack Israeli or Jewish institutions.
Piker wants to explain Palestinian terrorism exclusively through opposition to “occupation.”
But violence against Jews preceded the occupation he blames for it, crossed borders thousands of miles beyond it, and continues to target Jewish civilians with no connection to Israeli government policy.
That same determination to explain away Palestinian terrorism was evident when the conversation turned to October 7.
When Klein asked directly whether October 7 constituted terrorism, Piker acknowledged war crimes, described the attacks as horrifying and insisted he had never condoned them.
Yet that assertion is difficult to reconcile with his previous remarks about sexual violence during the Hamas-led massacre. Whether rapes occurred, he declared, did not “change the dynamic” for him.
And now, according to Piker, October 7 had “almost become an inevitability, really.”
Inevitability is how terrorism is justified and turns human choices into a natural disaster, as though murder, hostage-taking, and sexual assault were simply the automatic consequences of political pressure.
Even if one accepted every premise of Piker’s account of occupation, why would that make the slaughter of families in their homes inevitable?
Why attack a music festival? Why abduct civilians? Why commit acts of sexual violence?
There is a categorical difference between explaining the conditions in which an armed movement emerges and explaining away the decisions it makes.
Piker’s inevitability argument removes from Hamas the very responsibility he demands, in absolute terms, from Israel.
1/4
Hasan Piker has a problem. And it’s called Hamas.So why does the @nytimes keep giving him a platform to defend it?
Piker: “The attitude is that [Hamas] are expressly animated by Jew hatred. That’s not the case… It is a national emancipatory front. That’s all they care about is the end to the occupation.”
Really?
If Palestinian terrorism is simply about ending the “occupation,” why have Palestinians repeatedly attacked Jews THOUSANDS of miles from Israel?
– Antwerp, 1980: A Palestinian terrorist throws grenades at Jewish children waiting for a summer camp bus.
– Vienna, 1981: Palestinian terrorists attack a synagogue during a bar mitzvah.
– Paris, 1982: Palestinian terrorists open fire and throw grenades at a Jewish restaurant.
– Rome, 1982: Palestinian terrorists attack worshippers outside the Great Synagogue.
– Istanbul, 1986: Palestinian terrorists massacre 22 Jewish worshippers inside a synagogue.These weren’t Israeli military installations. They were Jewish civilian targets.
Hamas 1988 charter: “Our struggle against the Jews is very great and very serious.”
Senior Hamas leader Fathi Hammad in 2019: “Attack every Jew on the globe.”
Piker’s Hamas problem is that the terrorist group’s words and actions expose the lie at the heart of his defense.
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) November 16, 2026
From the Nazis to the KKK
Klein played a recording in which Piker described Zionism as an “exterminationist ideology” and compared liberal Zionists to “liberal Nazis.”
When challenged, Piker conceded that the comparison was “hyperbolic” but insisted, “I don’t mind using this kind of incendiary language.”
But this goes far beyond incendiary language. It is Holocaust inversion—the weaponization of Jewish history against Jews themselves.
Supporters of Jewish self-determination become the ideological heirs of those who sought to exterminate the Jewish people.
The victims become the perpetrators. The Holocaust is recast as a universal metaphor, stripped of its defining reality: the systematic extermination of European Jewry.
And the implications of Piker’s rhetoric are deeply sinister. If Zionists are Nazis, hatred of them becomes anti-fascism. Violence toward them can be rationalized as resistance to history’s ultimate evil.
Piker deploys the same tactic when comparing Jewish voters to the Ku Klux Klan.
In another recording played by Klein, Piker likened campaigning for Abdul El-Sayed in a predominantly Jewish Michigan district to canvassing a KKK neighborhood for a Black candidate.
Klein objected: “I think it’s crazy to describe an entire neighborhood of Jewish people whose positions you actually don’t know as akin to KKK members.”
The KKK was a white-supremacist terrorist organization responsible for lynchings, murders, intimidation, and the violent enforcement of racial segregation. Its victims included Black Americans and Jews.
Yet Piker invokes this history to characterize Jewish voters whose politics he dislikes. Liberal Zionists become Nazis.
Jewish voters become Klansmen. Supporting Israel becomes evidence of being a proponent of racial supremacy.
The pattern is clear: people who disagree with Piker are not merely wrong but are equivalent to history’s most notorious racists and murderers.
Utopian Solutions, Inconvenient Realities
Piker entertains the prospect of replacing Israel with a single secular state guaranteeing equal rights, alongside other possible political arrangements.
But how would such a state protect its Jewish population? Who would disarm Hamas? What would prevent civil war or the persecution of minorities?
And how would an organization committed to Israel’s destruction suddenly become a guarantor of Jewish rights?
These are fundamental questions Piker seems content to leave unanswered.
He is equally comfortable describing liberal Zionism as an exterminationist ideology while cooperating politically with self-described liberal Zionists such as Brad Lander.
One can hardly insist that an ideology is comparable to Nazism while treating its adherents as perfectly acceptable political allies. That Piker apparently sees no contradiction speaks volumes about his intellectual rigor.
His prescription for American foreign policy is similarly sweeping: immediately terminate “all aid, all arms transfers and the memorandum of understanding” with Israel and apply “maximum pressure.”
What happens to Israel’s defensive capabilities? What pressure would be exerted on Hamas? How does weakening Israel’s defenses produce the peaceful, pluralistic society Piker claims to want?
These are the questions that should accompany such sweeping pronouncements.
Yet the New York Times has repeatedly provided Piker with a prestigious platform on which his most extreme positions can be presented as serious political ideas.
And therein lies the problem with the paper’s Piker obsession.
Imagine a far-right influencer comparing an entire Jewish neighborhood to the KKK, likening supporters of Jewish self-determination to Nazis and dismissing the antisemitism of a terrorist organization responsible for massacring Jews.
Would such rhetoric be treated as merely provocative? Would its author be celebrated as a fascinating political voice whose influence deserved repeated exploration?
Consider the New York Times’ own editorial framing.
When the newspaper profiled Nick Fuentes in September 2025, it identified him as “A White Nationalist Problem for the Right.”
When it profiled Hasan Piker in April 2025, the headline was “A Progressive Mind in a MAGA Body.”
One is defined by his extremism. The other is packaged as an intriguing political personality.
The issue isn’t whether the New York Times should interview controversial figures. It’s whether extremism receives the same scrutiny regardless of its political origins.
In this case, repeated exposure has consequences: antisemitic rhetoric has been normalized as political provocation, and the demonization of Jews has become another seemingly respectable subject for debate.
By repeatedly presenting Piker in such a flattering light, the New York Times has helped usher extremism into acceptable political discourse.
Do You Love Israel? Make a Donation - Show Your Support!
Donate to vital charities that help protect Israeli citizens and inspire millions around the world to support Israel too!
Now more than ever, Israel needs your help to fight and win the war -- including on the battlefield of public opinion.
Antisemitism, anti-Israel bias and boycotts are out of control. Israel's enemies are inciting terror and violence against innocent Israelis and Jews around the world. Help us fight back!
STAND WTH ISRAEL - MAKE A DONATION TODAY!

