Archbishop of Canterbury Suggests Israel to Blame for Decline in Christian Palestinians

By Rachel O’Donoghue, Honest Reporting

Church of England head Justin Welby has issued a grave warning about the future of Christians living in the Holy Land, in an article published on December 19 in the Sunday Times.

The piece, which was jointly authored with Palestinian Anglican Bishop Hosam Naoum, was penned in response to a statement earlier this month from church leaders in Jerusalem, who warned the actions of radical groups are “diminishing the Christian presence” in the area.

Such acts, they contend, have included the desecration of churches, as well as physical and verbal attacks on priests, monks and worshipers.

Offering some stark statistics to illustrate their point, Welby and Naoum state:

“This crisis takes place against a century-long decline in the Christian population in the Holy Land. In 1922, at the end of the Ottoman era, the number of Christians in the Holy Land was estimated at 73,000; about 10 percent of the population. In 2019, Christians constituted less than 2 percent of the population of the Holy Land: a massive drop in less than 100 years.”

They concede in the following paragraph, however, that the Christian population in Israel proper has actually grown.

Who, then, are these vague “radical groups” and from where exactly are Christians being driven out?

Islamic Extremists in PA Territory

Unlike Archbishop Welby and Bishop Naoum, global Christian charity Open Doors did not mince words when it attributed the steep decline of Christians to “Islamic oppression,” explaining “Islamic extremist militants” in the Palestinian Authority-administered West Bank were causing Christians to fear violent attacks.

A 2019 report by Edy Cohen of the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies went into even more detail.

Citing three incidents that encapsulate the persecution of Palestinian Christians, Cohen noted that the cases had received precious little attention because they are “not connected to Israel.”

One such episode on April 25, 2019, involved Christian residents of Jifna, near Ramallah, who begged the PA for protection after Muslim gunmen stormed their village in response to a woman living there having complained to police that the son of a Fatah-affiliated leader had attacked her family.

Rather than protecting an innocent civilian, police turned a blind eye as armed rioters connected to Fatah, the political party that controls the Palestinian Authority, lobbed petrol bombs at homes and fired live rounds into the air. Witnesses later reported that the men had demanded the village’s residents pay a “jizya” — a tax historically levied on non-Muslim minorities living under Islamic rule.

In the other two incidents, vandals broke into churches in Bethlehem and Ramallah and desecrated the religious sites.

Cohen points out that cases like these are likely just the tip of the iceberg, as many Christians avoid speaking out about persecution over fears that they will be targeted for retribution and the “Muslim aggression against them will only escalate.”

The steep decline of the Christian population has been equally dramatic in Gaza.

In 2005, when Israel unilaterally withdrew from the territory, dismantling 21 Israeli settlements and evacuating some 9,000 Jewish residents in the process, there were approximately 5,000 Christians living in the coastal enclave.

Two years later, US-designated terrorist group Hamas violently seized control of the Strip and imposed Islamic law (Sharia), while Hamas-affiliated groups like Swords of Righteousness and the Army of Islam began targeting Christians with kidnappings, murders, forced conversions and attacks on churches and Christian-owned businesses.

Today, just 1,000 Christians remain in Gaza.

‘Fringe Radical Groups’

Yet this is how Welby and Naoum summarize the reasons for Christians fleeing Palestinian lands in droves:

“Christians in Israel enjoy democratic and religious freedoms that are a beacon in the region. But the escalation of physical and verbal abuse of Christian clergy, and the vandalism of holy sites by fringe radical groups, are a concerted attempt to intimidate and drive them away. Meanwhile, the growth of settler communities and travel restrictions brought about by the West Bank separation wall have deepened the isolation of Christian villages and curtailed economic and social possibilities.”

It is striking that in the entire article, the Palestinian Authority and Hamas are not mentioned once, with attacks on Christians instead attributed to these mysterious “fringe radical groups.”

Despite a wealth of evidence to the contrary, Welby and Naoum also appear to suggest that the reason for the precipitous decline in Christians is the result of growing “settler communities” and Israeli “travel restrictions.”

This is not to say there have not been incidents of settler violence. Indeed, HonestReporting has acknowledged such reports, which have been widely condemned by Israeli leaders from across the political spectrum.

Yet, the facts are that such acts by Jewish extremists are incredibly rare and, without diminishing the appalling nature of such attacks, the vast majority of them are perpetrated against Muslim Arabs, not Christians.

Welby and Naoum also failed to note that the demise of Christians in Palestinian-controlled areas is part of a general pattern of Christians disappearing from Muslim lands around the world.

A 2019 report published by then-UK foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt painted a perilous picture of Christians in the Middle East, with data showing that their number had plummeted from 20 percent of the population a century ago to five percent.

Welby and Naoum are rightly concerned about the grim future of Christians in the birthplace of their religion, but by steadfastly refusing to call out who is responsible for this oppression, they do a great disservice to those they should be protecting.